Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Holy Cap!

The salary cap (either version) shouldn't be that hard to understand. Perhaps Zach and I are partially guilty of a confused presentation of our ideas. It is my wish to remedy any confusion with this post.

As it stands, there is a somewhat massive imbalance of talent in the league. This also leaves the better teams with vast amounts of resources to acquire future talent (see: Offseason 2008-09, Connor trades Harang, Ankiel, McGowan and Cabrera to acquire Matt Wieters).

A worse-off team than mine may not have been able to pay the price to move up and get Wieters.

The salary cap, by definition, gives each team the same amount of resources to acquire and accumulate talent. Each team will (eventually) have $260 with which pay their players. No more, no less.

Usually, salaries are established at the league's creation through an open auction. Since we did a snake draft instead, we currently have no player salaries. There are a couple of ways to remedy this problem:

1) Determine player salaries based on PECOTA projections (Zach's proposal)*
2) Determine player salaries based on past-season performance (Connor's proposal)

After we initially set salaries by either of these methods, my proposal is that prices would be set by the market going forward. We would agree on a rate for salary inflation (say, $3/year), and if the owner of Torii Hunter was willing to pay $15 for Torii Hunter in 2008 but is not willing to pay $18 in 2009, Hunter can be cut. Hunter will then be bid on and auctioned off. His salary will be determined by the prevailing market price (say, $12).

This obviously gives more value to young, cheap players that can be picked up off of free agents for $1 and experience a modest price increase each season, creating a good chance that they will overperform their salary for many years. But you aren't going to win a league with a bunch of $1 rookies (Zach's apparent strategy for this season notwithstanding).

If you still have questions, I encourage you to go through the Google Doc emailed out by Zach. I'm still not 100% done with my proposal, but most of the meat should be on there. If you're unable to view the Doc, let Zach know.


*While setting these prices retroactively is something of a tricky subject leaving it impossible to be completely fair to everyone, I can't justify the logic of setting retroactive prices using projections of the future. This could be particularly cruel to the managers that this new system was meant to most help, given the gaudy PECOTA projections for some young players currently on under-performing (is that the correct PC lingo?) teams.... Thus, my opposition to Zach's sub-idea.


Addendum: There are no "picks" under this system (also, there are no "picks" under the current system). There is only "cap space". It's just like every other major professional sport except baseball. e.g., The Panthers have $20 million in cap space. Therefore, they sign Player A at $8 million, Player B at $4 million, Player C at $5 million, and Player D at $3 million. You might even say that these players are "auctioned" on the open market and the highest-bidding team wins the player. Yeah, it costs money to sign Peyton Manning, but with it comes the benefit of Peyton Manning's production.

Monday, March 16, 2009

Sunday, March 15, 2009

Geithner...

Does anyone else feel like Tim Geithner could learn something from the level of detail that Connor and Zach are offering to "fix" a "broken" system?

Saturday, March 14, 2009

Salary Cap

I have e-mailed everybody a copy of my proposed salary cap idea, current player salaries and a team by team breakdown of player salaries. I also posted this on Google Docs for everyone to see (I apologize if I sent multiple e-mails. Google kept saying their server was down but then it sent the invites anyway. )

Comment back on here and let me know if the general idea sounds good. If so, we can work on editing the rules throughout the season and implement it next offseason.

Friday, March 13, 2009

Team Dollar Values

These are the 2009 BP PFM (Baseball Prospectus Player Forecast Manager) results for the current dollar value of each player's team:

Steve - 276
Zach - 283
Lance - 351
Markham - 289
Matt - 268
Connor - 259
Bick - 191
Eric - 183
Andy S - 133
Elliot - 153
JRoss - 234
Nick - 261
Jamie - 178
Kyle - 224

If we switched to mine and Connor's salary cap idea, this would be how much you are paying for your team. This was using a 260 dollar salary cap, and right now the average team salary is 235. Is anyone else interested in a salary cap idea?
how are the draft dollars at the end of the year calculated?

also (copied from our Yahoo League forum):

ake note I don't expect to be in the bottom 5 again this year, but after having been there 3 years I think this is only fair to help the turn-around. 

Officially motioning the following things.... 

1) Reverse, line-order draft to replace the draft dollars. While the idea of the draft dollars is nice, some people just don't want to or can't take the time to play the system. The top 5 teams from last year benefited the most this offseason and that's BS. We're here to help the bottom not make this a league for 5 people. The picks, like draft dollars are tradeable, but only after they have been announced. 

2) Bottom 5 people are reverse order 1-5 on waiver priority at the start of the next year (6-end would stay the same order as it was previously). This allows anyone who isn't in the draft or other prospects to head to those bottom teams. Just a little more advantage. 

3) Trades themselves take only 5 vetos (1/3 of the league) unless another 3rd party "likes" the trade and posts as such. In that case 1 additional person is required for each person who likes it. Off season as well. 

4) Offseason trades take just as long to go through as season trades (unless 1/3 of the people are in the same place... aka chatroom, phone conference, etc, etc). That keeps people from calling everyone last minute because they HAVE TO make a trade. 


I don't care if we take part of this, but we need to have 1-3 I think for this league to become more fair as a keepers league.


In Defense of the Auction Draft

Now that the draft is over, I wanted to defend the auction style. Remember, the purpose of the auction draft was to distribute dollars in order of finish - I decided to see how the draft might have worked out, assuming no one traded any draft dollars. I also took out any players drafted for $1.

To Kyle: Wieters and Billy Butler (and 15$ for remaining players bid at $1)
To Jamie: N. Feliz and Mark Lowe (and 25$ remaining)
To Nick: Cahill and Willis (and 6$ remaining)
To JR: Hanson (and 9$ remaining)
To Andy S: LaPorta (0$ remaining)
To Elliot: Tillman (11$ remaining)
To Eric: Tazawa (36$ remaining)
To Bick: Brett Wallace (32$ remaining)
To Connor: Lars Anderson (51$ remaining)
To Matt: E Andrus (33$ remaining)
To Andrew: Gil Meche (12$ remaining)
To Lance: Homer Bailey (8$ remaining)
To Zach: R Soriano (0$ remaining)
To Steve: K Gregg and JR Towles (9$ remaining)

Players at $1:

Cabrera, Asdrubal
Cabrera, Daniel
Dickerson, Chirs
Gallagher, Sean
Griffey, Jr., Ken
Napoli, Mike
Ross, Cody
Ross, David
Sheffield. Gary
Weeks, Rickie
Wigginton, Ty
Zito, Barry


As you can see, if people had valued their draft dollars appropriately, then the result would have been similar to a snake draft. Perhaps a good way to get an auction draft to work is to not allow the trading of draft dollars. Some managers took adavantage of others who did not appropriately understand the value of their draft dollars - we're fantasy baseball players, not saints.